Home After 20 years, Maumee Bay starts to freeze again
After 20 years, Maumee Bay starts to freeze again
Written by Kelly Kaczala   
Thursday, 03 January 2013 16:28

Oregon Councilwoman Sandy Bihn, who is also Western Lake Erie Waterkeeper, said winter activities on Maumee Bay once enjoyed by residents are now returning, thanks to cooler temperatures and less heated water being discharged from FirstEnergy’s power plant on Bay Shore Road.

“Most of the Oregon shoreline along Maumee Bay is freezing - at least for now.  What a treat,” said Bihn. “We may be able to once again skate, ice fish, etc.” 

When Bihn’s family moved to their current home on Bay Shore Road in 1987, the ice on the bay was thick.

“We were able to go out on the ice and walk along the shoreline on ice.  It was great,” she said.  “But all of a sudden, we couldn’t do it anymore.”

Bihn said in the 1990s, Maumee Bay stopped freezing over.

“I called many people and asked why and was told any number of supposed reasons, but no one mentioned the Bay Shore power plant,” said Bihn.

The plant, located on the south shore of Lake Erie, near the confluence of the Maumee River and Maumee Bay in Oregon, had added another unit and increased the amount of water it used by about 200 million gallons a day.  Many power plants use water for cooling. The water that is discharged from the Bay Shore plant, often referred to as a “thermal plume,” is about 10 degrees warmer than the water taken in, according to Bihn. 

“For nearly 20 years, I watched the so called 'thermal plume' keep the waters from freezing, from the plant to Maumee Bay State Park - over two miles in distance. Going out on the ice was unsafe,” said Bihn. 

The Bay Shore plant, which at one time used up to 750 million gallons of water per day, has closed three of its four units, due to FirstEnergy’s announcement earlier this year that it would close several power plants because of air emission standards imposed by the Environmental Protection Agency. As a result, the Bay Shore plant has reduced its daily water usage by over 500 million gallons a day, said Bihn. And that, she believes, has allowed the bay to freeze over once again.

“About 500 million gallons of water less per day are being used in 2013 than in 1987,” said Bihn.  Less water use also means less fish kills, she added, “over hundreds of millions less.” Bihn is referring to the plant’s cooling water intake system, which, according to studies, has killed millions of fish, fish larvae and eggs. It has long been a controversial topic to environmentalists because the fish, according to Bihn, come from the warmest, shallowest, and most biologically productive waters of the Great Lakes.

The Ohio EPA for years reviewed options for the Bay Shore power plant to reduce the fish kills. The plant agreed in 2010 to install devices called “reverse louvers” to address the problem, though Bihn believed that the installation of the more expensive cooling towers would have been more effective.

A new power plant, which will break ground in Oregon in May on 30 acres of land just south of the BP Husky Refinery, between Wynn and Lallendorf roads, will help fill the gap being left by the phase out of the coal fired Bay Shore power plant. But the new gas fired plant, which will convert natural gas to electricity, is not expected to have the same impact that the Bay Shore plant had on fish, said Bihn, because it will use less water.

Bihn plans to take a walk on the frozen bay soon, she said.

“We should be able to enjoy a frozen Oregon Maumee Bay shore line this winter - if it is cold enough,” she said.

She warned the public to check the ice and make sure it’s frozen solid before walking on it.

“If you want to venture out on the ice, please be careful that the ice is thick enough and safe. Hopefully there will be 'safe ice' allowing ice fishing and ice skating once more at Oregon on the bay,” she said.

Comments (4)Add Comment
Inaccurate article to say the least
posted by Mr. Corduroy, January 05, 2013
When I first moved here to Oregon I would brag about this local paper and how much it exceeded my former newspaper (which I worked for) in all categories. Sadly, I now have to question this paper and it reporting. Why was FirstEnergy not sought for comment on this. This article states nothing about their comments. Even a little bit of investigation would show that the Bay Shore Plant has always had the same amount of intake pumps and the same amount of discharge since 1968. The new unit that was put in 12 years ago replaced a unit that was retired. The condensers (the part that really matters) did not change, in fact this "new unit" is using a condenser that is original equipment, not a new installation.

Also, the OEPA ruled against the reverse louver system at this facility. Kind of odd that as citizen of the community, and even worse a new one, knows this information but a city council person does not. Even worse the journalist responsible for reporting the story only relies on one source to print a front page story. All of this info is public record through the OEPA. Also, if you take a look at the public records you will see that this 10 degree difference is not really the most true statement either.

The 2012/2013 data has not been released yet, so how can Sandy or the reporter state how many gallons are being used?

I expect more from my media outlets and my elected officials.
posted by Mr. Corduroy, January 05, 2013
I almost forgot, I was on Bay Shore Rd. by the veterans park sledding with the kids a couple times this last week. The bay looked pretty open to me.
Maumee Bay Freezing
posted by Sandy Bihn, January 07, 2013
At least for now, Maumee is not freezing. Warm weather. Lake Erie needs to freeze to reduce winter evaporation. Our low water levels will get worse if the lake does not freeze.
As to the comments on the bay article. Ohio EPA issues a Permit to Install(PTI) the louvers to reduce the fish kills in July 2011. There have been some modifications but the louvers have not been installed because of the reduction in the number of operating units from four to one.
There were five units - four coal and one oil. THe oil unit was shut down. In 1998 BP had an agreement to replace the 1968 coal fired unit with Pet coke as the fuel source. This is the only remaining running unit - though the company can restart the three units that are shut down. As a result of the closure of the three units, the colume of water heated and discharged had dropped from 749 million gallons a day to 182 million gallons a day. The lower volume of water save hundreds of millions of larval fish and reduces the amount of heated water discharged. It is the reduced heated water that will allow more of the Oregon shoreline along Maumee Bay to freeze. As said before, it is important to make sure the ice is thick enough and safe before venturing out.
posted by anonymousinoregon45, January 09, 2013
"The lower volume of water save hundreds of millions of larval fish and reduces the amount of heated water discharged."

Its really too bad that people are more worried about the fish than they are about the people who lost their JOBS.

But hey whats one more welfare recipient as long as the people who own property along the shore can fish and go ice skating once it freezes again right?

Post a comment
Login on the right column to post a comment. Please register if you do not have an account yet.


By: Kelly Kaczala

Contact e-mail: This e-mail address is being protected from spambots. You need JavaScript enabled to view it

Show Other Articles



If you found a penny on the floor, would you pick it up?

The Current Weather for Millbury, OH USA


Log in